How Can Our
Community Help Limit the Rat Population in Harlem?
Class 801
Ms. R. Jones
INTRODUCTION
The presence of rats will
always be an inconvenience to homes and commercial buildings. For many, this is
the nastiest nuisance that any property can ever have. No one wants to live in
a home where you know germs and other diseases may be lingering around simply
because there are rats. As to community buildings, clients can be turned off
when they see rats running through the area. Restaurants in Harlem have had
many problems and citations because rats have gotten into establishments and
destroyed food and other necessities for business.
Rats are various medium sized, long
tailed rodents. Species of rats are found throughout the order Rodentia, but
stereotypical rats are found in the genus Rattus. They are typically
distinguished from mice by their size . There are 56
known species of rats in the world.
Rat sightings in Harlem have reached
their highest total on record, last year and are on pace to surpass that number
in 2023 according to 311 complaint data. In 2023, residents of Harlem have
spotted rats 2114 times which will pass the total of 2022 sightings of 2298
rats. Something needs to be done in our community to eliminate this annoying,
disgusting problem.
TASK
During this unit, we will
take some time to focus on the real-world problem of rats in our neighborhood
of Harlem. You will be divided into
groups of three and you will be responsible for putting together a presentation
that will give us ideas about how we can help stop the growing rat population
in our Harlem Community. Your group will also be responsible for writing a
letter to the Manhattan Borough President, Mark Levin and give him your group
ideas on how to stop the rodent population in Harlem.
PROCESS/RESOURCES
In your group, you will work
together and use the steps of the PPA in order to do your research for the
project. Over the next few days in class, you will be using the PPA Process to
create a presentation of your findings and to write a group letter to Mark
Levine Manhattan Boro President. The steps of the PPA
Process are the following:
1. Define the Problem
2. Gather Evidence
3. Identify the cause
4. Evaluate the Existing Policy
5. Develop a Solution
6. Select the Best Solution
Day One: Define the Problem and Gather
Evidence
There
are a lot of rats in the Harlem Community. In your groups, you will research
and show how serious the rat problem is in Harlem. You will use the laptops in
order to do this task. I will provide you with a few resources.
https://patch.com/new-york/harlem/harlem-rat-sightings-approach-record-high-2022-heres-where
https://pavementpieces.com/rats-are-thriving-in-new-york-city/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MN9z4HesTMs
Once
you have reviewed the two articles, fill out the worksheet defining the
problem.
·
Worksheet 1: Defining the Problem https://flippedtips.com/plegal/tips/worksheet1.doc
·
Worksheet 2: Gather the Evidence of the Problem https://flippedtips.com/plegal/tips/worksheet2.doc
·
Worksheet 3: Identifying the Causes of the Problem https://flippedtips.com/plegal/tips/worksheet3.doc
Day Three: Evaluate existing policy
Today you will look at policies that
are in place for your problem and then you will evaluate them using the
worksheet provided. I have provided you with some sites to get you started on
this task.
https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/ehs/docs/vector-profiles/nyc-ny.pdf
https://patch.com/new-york/harlem/harlem-rats-could-be-scuttled-new-bills-complaints-keep-rising
https://abc7ny.com/nyc-new-york-city-council-rats-rat-action-plan/12384799/
https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/nyc-war-on-rats-can-4-new-rodent-laws-fix-the-crisis/3963953/
Worksheet 4: Evaluating Existing Public
Policies https://flippedtips.com/plegal/tips/worksheet4.doc
Day Four: Develop Solutions
For this step, you will look back at
the policies you evaluated in the day three assignment. Use the following
worksheet to develop possible solutions for the problem.
Worksheet 5: Developing Public
Policy Solutions https://flippedtips.com/plegal/tips/worksheet5.doc
Day Five: Select the best Solution
For this
final step, you will use the worksheet to analyze and select the best solution
that will solve the problem.
Worksheet 6: Select the Best
Solution https://flippedtips.com/plegal/tips/worksheet6.doc
EVALUATION
Task |
Great Job 4 |
Good 3 |
Almost 2 |
Not evident 1 |
Group Work |
Worked well in group |
Worked well with some/all of the
group |
Worked with some group members |
Did not engage with the group during
the project. |
Knowledge and content and research |
Used multiple sources to research
rat problem in Harlem |
Used two sources to research rat
problem in Harlem |
Used one source to research rat
problem in Harlem |
Did not use any sources to
research the rat problem in Harlem. |
Presentation and letter to Boro President |
Includes all steps of the PPA and
letter highlights solutions to rat problem. |
Includes some of the steps of the
PPA and letter highlights some solutions to rat problem. |
Includes less than three steps of
the PPA and not many solutions for the rat problem in the letter. |
None of the steps of the PPA
included and no letter provided or no solutions for the rat problem in the
letter. |
CONCLUSION
Throughout
this project, you have worked in groups to find a solution to the rat problem
in our beloved Harlem. You have done research, looked at policies, created a
presentation and wrote a letter to our Manhattan Borough President. You have
also come up with solutions that you feel that would best eliminate the rat
problem in Harlem.
STANDARDS
READING
STANDARDS FOR LITERACY IN SCIENCE AND TECHNICAL SUBJECTS 6-8 Key Ideas and
Details
RST1: Cite
specific evidence to support analysis of scientific and technical texts,
charts, graphs, diagrams, etc. Understand and follow a detailed set of
directions.
RST2:
Determine the central ideas or conclusions of a source; provide an accurate,
objective summary of the source distinct from prior knowledge or opinions.
RST3:
Describe how and why scientific ideas and reasoning are developed and modified
over the course of a text, source, argument, etc. Craft and Structure RST4:
Determine the meaning of symbols, key terms, and other content-specific words.
NGSS Science
Standards
Evaluate competing design solutions for
maintaining biodiversity and ecosystem services.*
Performance Expectation
Grade:
Middle School (6-8)
|
|